Guide · Homeowners · 3 min read · Updated 17 November 2026
PIV vs Dehumidifier vs MVHR: Which Is Best for Condensation?
Short answer
For whole-house condensation in an existing home, a PIV unit is usually the best value: one unit, fitted in a few hours, running continuously with little maintenance. Dehumidifiers suit single rooms or short-term drying but need emptying and cost more to run. MVHR gives the best performance with heat recovery but needs ducting to every room, so it suits new builds and major refurbishments.
The main options at a glance
Each approach tackles indoor humidity differently. Some remove moisture from the air, some replace moist air with fresh air and some do both. The table sets out the practical differences for a typical UK home.
| Option | How it works | Best for | Main drawback |
|---|---|---|---|
| PIV unit | Supplies filtered air, pushing moist air out | Whole existing houses and flats | Does not recover heat from exhaust air |
| Portable dehumidifier | Condenses water from room air | Single rooms, drying laundry | Emptying, noise, higher running cost |
| Extract fans | Remove moist air at source | Kitchens and bathrooms | Only treat the room they are in |
| MVHR | Supply and extract with heat exchange | New builds, deep retrofits | Ducting to every room, higher cost |
Positive input ventilation
A PIV unit treats the whole house from one point. Fitted in the loft or on an external wall, it runs continuously at low speed and creates slight positive pressure, so moist air leaves through natural gaps. Installation takes a few hours and costs £650–£1,100 for a loft unit or £750–£1,250 for a wall unit in a flat.
The strengths are simplicity and consistency. Nobody has to remember to switch it on, there is no tank to empty and the fan uses very little electricity. The limitation is that it does not recover heat from the air leaving the house, though a tempering heater and the warmth of loft air keep the supply comfortable.
Dehumidifiers
A portable dehumidifier pulls room air over a cold coil or desiccant wheel and collects the water in a tank. It works well in a single problem room, for drying laundry indoors or for drying out after a leak. It is also useful for renters who cannot alter the property.
As a whole-house solution it struggles. One unit cannot reach every room, the tank needs emptying unless it is piped to a drain, and running costs are higher than a PIV fan. It also does nothing about stale air, smells or the build-up of indoor pollutants, because no fresh air is brought in.
- Good for one room or short-term drying
- Useful where you cannot alter the building
- Needs regular emptying and cleaning
- Does not bring in fresh air
Extract fans
Kitchen and bathroom extract fans remove moisture where most of it is produced, before it spreads through the house. They are a requirement when wet rooms are built or refitted, and Approved Document F sets minimum extract rates in England. Humidity-controlled and continuous-running fans work far better than old fans on a light switch that stop as soon as someone leaves.
Extract fans are not an alternative to PIV so much as a partner. Fans deal with the source, and PIV dilutes moisture everywhere else. If your fans are weak or not ducted outside, replacing them, from £180–£350 each, is often the first step.
Mechanical ventilation with heat recovery
MVHR extracts stale air from wet rooms and supplies fresh air to living rooms and bedrooms, passing both streams through a heat exchanger so most of the warmth in the outgoing air is transferred to the incoming air. In a very airtight home it delivers excellent air quality and low heat loss.
The catch is installation. MVHR needs a central unit and ducting to every room, which is straightforward in a new build but disruptive in an occupied home with finished ceilings. It also needs regular filter changes and periodic duct checks. For most existing homes with condensation, it is more than is needed.
Running effort and costs compared
Purchase price is only part of the picture. A dehumidifier is cheap to buy but needs emptying, filter cleaning and moving from room to room, and its compressor or heater draws noticeably more power than a PIV fan. If it is switched off because it is noisy or full, the condensation returns within days.
A PIV unit costs more upfront but then largely looks after itself, with a filter change at the interval the manufacturer recommends and an occasional service. MVHR has the highest installation cost and needs filters changing more often, though it recovers heat that would otherwise be lost. Extract fans cost little to run and should be on every list regardless of the main choice.
- Dehumidifier: low purchase cost, daily effort, higher power use
- PIV: moderate cost, minimal effort, low power use
- MVHR: highest cost, regular filter changes, heat recovery
- Extract fans: low cost, essential in wet rooms
How to choose
Start by confirming the problem is condensation rather than a leak or rising damp. Then consider the property: a house with a usable loft suits a loft PIV unit, a flat suits a wall-mounted PIV, and a gut renovation or new build may justify MVHR. Make sure extract fans in wet rooms are working regardless.
We arrange condensation assessments and PIV installation through vetted, insured local installers. You get one fixed price for the solution agreed, including any fan upgrades.
- Existing house with loft: loft-mounted PIV
- Flat or no loft: wall-mounted PIV
- Single room or renting: dehumidifier
- New build or full refurbishment: consider MVHR
Questions people also ask
Can I use a dehumidifier and PIV together?
Yes, though most homes find they no longer need a dehumidifier once PIV is running and extract fans work properly. A dehumidifier can still be handy for drying laundry indoors or tackling one stubborn room while the house dries out. Over time, many owners stop using it altogether.
Is MVHR worth retrofitting to an older house?
It can be in a deep retrofit where the house is being made much more airtight and ceilings are coming down anyway. In a lived-in older home with normal draughts, the heat recovery benefit is smaller and the disruption larger, so PIV and good extract fans usually give better value.
Do I need to replace my extract fans when fitting PIV?
Not always, but check them. Fans that are weak, noisy, not ducted outside or switched only with the light will limit how well the house dries out. Your installer can test their performance and, if needed, replace them with humidity-controlled or continuous models at the same visit.
Written and checked by the PIV Unit Installation team. Read our editorial policy.
More guides
How Much Does a PIV Unit Cost to Install in the UK?
A loft-mounted PIV unit typically costs £650–£1,100 supplied and fitted in the UK, including the unit, heater, diffuser, ducting and connection to an…
Does Positive Input Ventilation Work? How PIV Stops Condensation
Yes, positive input ventilation works well where condensation and mould are caused by high indoor humidity and poor ventilation. The unit pushes…
Loft vs Wall-Mounted PIV: Choosing the Right Unit for Your Home
Choose a loft-mounted PIV unit if you live in a house or bungalow with an accessible loft; it uses warmer loft air and typically costs £650–£1,100…
Damp and Mould in Rented Homes: A Landlord's Guide to PIV Units
Landlords in England must keep rented homes free from serious hazards under the Housing Health and Safety Rating System, which includes damp and…
Get a free piv unit installation quote
Tell us what you need and we'll come back with a clear price.
Request a quote